Parents' hope of new safety laws following son's 'absolutely needless' tractor death

Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now
The heartbroken parents of a trainee mechanic, who died while helping repair a tractor, have said they hope his “absolutely needless” death will prompt a change in the law.

South West College student Neil Graham, 17, (pictured) lost his life in Enniskillen in 2018 working underneath the vehicle whilst on work placement.

Two Co Fermanagh men and a farming business – C and V Loane Limited of Derrybrick Road in Kesh – were yesterday handed fines totalling £50,000 for health and safety breaches.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Neil's parents Joy and Eddie travelled from their home Garrison to Belfast to attend the sentencing hearing along with other members of the family.

Neil GrahamNeil Graham
Neil Graham

Eddie said his son was full of "fun and adventure" and was pursuing his dream job as a mechanic. Joy her much-loved son could fix anything “and was so loyal and dependable”.

Speaking after the fines were imposed, she expressed the hope that what happened to Neil would lead to a change in the law regarding the use of tractors when they are in such as dangerous condition.

Gordon Brown, 63, of Boho Road in Enniskillen, admitted a charge of being an employer and failing to provide a safe system of work and was fined £20,000.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Jamie Loane, 27,, from Derrybrick Road in Kesh, pleaded guilty to a charge of being an employee and failing to take reasonable care for the health and safety of himself and others. A fine of £10,000 was also imposed upon him.

Loane's family farming business admitted a charge failing to ensure a non-employee was not exposed to risks to safety. It was also fined £20,000. All the charges relate to May 22, 2018.

Neil was on work placement with Brown's agricultural engineering firm in Enniskillen and on the day in question was working on a tractor brought in for repair by the Loane family.

Crown barrister Philip Mateer KC told the court that Brown "took the fatal decision to start that tractor” when Neil was lying underneath investigating an oil leak, causing the tractor to jump forward causing fatal injuries to the teenager.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

When the tractor was later examined, it emerged that a safety feature to prevent the vehicle being started whilst in gear had been bypassed some time before it was brought in for repair.

Brown later stated he was completely unaware of the modification and would not have allowed Neil anywhere near it had he known.

Frank O'Donoghue KC, acting on behalf of Jamie Loane and the company, said that whilst it was acknowledged by the Loane family that the Massey Ferguson brought to Brown was in a bad condition, they were not aware the modification had been made.